ONLINE
VIDEO Andrew Chugg's eleventh online video: Date Of Alexanders Accession - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's tenth online video: Alexander in Afghanistan - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's ninth online video: The Death of Hephaistion - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's eighth online video: The Life of Hephaistion - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's seventh online video: Barsine - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's sixth online video: Cleitarchus Reconstruction - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's fifth online video: Alexander's Journal - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's fourth online video: The death of Alexander the Great - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's third online video: Is Alexander in Venice? - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's second online video: The Tomb of Alexander in Memphis - Click here to watch now > Andrew Chugg's first online video: The Tomb of Alexander in Alexandria - Click here to watch now > For other videos please visit www.alexanderslovers.com |
Cleitarchus Reconstruction
Project for the Reconstruction of the History of Alexander by Cleitarchus
Books 1 to 4: in progress
Introduction
Alexander the Great and the Conquest of
the Persians
The most influential account of the
career of Alexander the Great was penned by Cleitarchus in the decades
after Alexander's death. Most of the surviving ancient texts on
Alexander were based upon his work, but every copy of the original was
destroyed in antiquity. Now the entire book is being revived in an
exciting reconstruction based upon an in-depth analysis of the surviving
ancient works that it inspired. This volume presents the section dealing
with Alexander's conquest of the Persians, from his initial defeat of
Darius at Issus in 333BC through to the death of the Persian Great King
in July of 330BC. This was the time when the earth began to shake upon
Alexander's every footfall. This was when anything and everything began
to seem possible. It was to something like this that Christopher Marlowe
alluded when he asked, Is it not passing brave to be a king and ride in
triumph through Persepolis? And yet frequently in Cleitarchus account
Alexander was compelled to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat.
Overwhelmingly outnumbered at Issus, he was also outflanked and
encircled at Gaugamela. On several occasions he came close to abandoning
the siege of Tyre and he nearly perished when he became lost in the
Libyan desert. This volume tells the thrilling tale of Alexander's
successive triumphs in the face of adversity.
|
Contents
1. |
Introduction |
1 |
2. |
Matters of Historical Relevance Is Arrian
Reliable?
The Three Peace Offers from Darius
. Dating Issues Including the Fall of
Tyre and Arbela. The
Appointment of the King of Sidon
. Did Alexander Visit Upper Egypt? The Location
of the Battle of Arbela or Gaugamela. The Burning
of Persepolis. Did Darius Agree To Surrender in July 330BC? Alexander�s
Route. |
6 |
3. |
Book 4: 25th September 333BC 13th
October 332BC The Battle of Issus; An Interview
with the Queens; The Treasures at Damascus; The First
Letter from Darius; A New King for Sidon
; The Siege of Tyre. |
37 |
4. |
Book 5: 14th October 332BC 1st October 331BC Second Peace Offer from Darius; The Siege
of Gaza; Occupation of Egypt
; Expedition to Siwa; Foundation of
Alexandria; The March back to Byblos; The
Preparations of Darius; Alexander's Advance into Mesopotamia;
Crossing the Tigris; Death of Stateira
; Third Peace Offer from Darius; The
Battle of Arbela. |
77 |
5. |
Book 6: October 2nd 331BC July 330BC The Escape of Darius
and the Capture of Treasure at
Arbela; Mennis and the Cave of
Naphtha; The Occupation of Babylon
; the Seizure of Susa; The Capture
of the Susian Gates
; Meeting with the Mutilated Greeks; The Burning
of Persepolis; The Pursuit of Darius and his Murder by Bessus. |
125 |
6. |
Organisation And Sources |
168 |
7. |
Bibliography |
202 |
8. |
Acknowledgements |
210 |
9. |
Index |
211 |
Images
Figure 2.1. The site of
the Battle of Arbela/Gaugamela |
Figure 4.5. Alexander and
Hephaistion visit the Persian Royal Family (Charles Le Brun) |
Figure 5.8. Alexander
directs an assault upon Tyre (Antonio Tempesta, 1608) |
Sample Chapter
Conquest_of_the_ Persians_sample.pdf
How to Buy
Available through Amazon and other online book stores from
February 2014.
Reviews
Not yet available.
Press Release
Not
yet available.
Books 5 & 6: Alexander the Great and the Defeat and Death of Darius
Introduction Alexander the Great and the Defeat and Death
of Darius
http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/help/customer/display.html/ref=hp_bc_nav?ie=UTF8&nodeId=200488000
|
|
Contents
1. |
Introduction |
|
|
|
|
Images
|
|
Fig. 5.3
Alexander is greeted as the Son of Zeus by the eldest priest at Siwa
(1696) |
Figure
6.10. Alexander cloaks the corpse of Darius |
Sample Section
Click on "Look Inside" on the Amazon Kindle page here:
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00BGVJCCY
How to Buy
|
|
Reviews
Not yet available.
Books 7 to 9: Alexander the Great in Afghanistan
Introduction
|
|
Contents
1. |
Introduction |
1 |
|
Introduction; Alexander's Emulation of Cyrus and the Persianising;
Geographical Errors; The Visit of the Queen of the Amazons; Prophthasia;
The Culpability of Philotas and Parmenion; The Condemnation of the
Branchidae; The Killing of Cleitus; The Culpability and Fates of
Callisthenes and the Pages; The Marriage to Roxane; Fragments of
Cleitarchus from Books Seven to Nine |
|
|
The Advance to Hecatompylus; Description of Hyrcania and the Caspian
Sea; Surrender of Artabazus & the Greek Mercenaries; Theft of
Bucephalus; Surrender of Nabarzanes; Visit of the Amazon Queen; Adoption
of Persian Dress; Revolt of Satibarzanes; The Philotas Affair;
Assassination of Parmenion; The Euergetae; First Crossing of the
Paropamisus Range
|
|
|
Alexander's Advance to the River Oxus; Bessus Betrayed to Alexander; The
Fate of the Branchidae; Alexander Wounded near Maracanda; The Revolt of
Spitamenes; Alexander's Advance to the River Tanais; Annihilation of a
Macedonian Column by Spitamenes and Alexander's Counterattacks; Capture
of the Rock of Ariamazes |
|
|
The Hunt in Basista; The Killing of Cleitus; The Treaty with
Sisimithres; The Decapitation of Spitamenes; The Proskynesis Experiment;
The Conspiracy of the Pages; The Army Caught in a Blizzard; The Marriage
to Roxane
|
117 |
6. |
Alexander's Route Through Afghanistan |
144 |
7. |
Organisation And Sources |
149 |
8. |
|
157 |
9. |
Bibliography |
186 |
10. |
Acknowledgements |
193 |
|
Index |
194 |
Images
|
|
Figure
2.1. Persian Dress (sketch by the author) |
Figure
9.3. Alexander consoled by the philosophers after killing Cleitus |
Sample Section
How to Buy
|
|
Reviews
Not yet available.
Press Release
Not yet available.
Books 10 to 12: Alexander the Great in India
Introduction
The most influential account of the career of Alexander the Great was
penned by Cleitarchus the son of Deinon, a Greek writing in Alexandria
in the decades after Alexander's death. Most of the surviving ancient
texts on Alexander were more or less based upon his work, but every
single copy of the original was discarded or destroyed in antiquity. To
what extent might it be possible to reconstruct it from the secondary
writings? This book argues that a considerable degree of reconstruction
is feasible and demonstrates the point by presenting a full
reconstruction of Cleitarchus� version of Alexander's campaigns in
India, the first time that this has been done.
|
|
Contents
1 |
Introduction |
1 |
|
A Basis For The Reconstruction of Cleitarchus |
3 |
3 |
Book 10: June 327BC June 326BC |
64 |
The Invasion Of India, Nysa, Mazaga, Aornus And The Battle Against Porus |
||
4 |
Book 11: July 326BC May 325BC |
93 |
Eastwards Through India, The Mutiny On The Hyphasis And The River Voyage
To The Siege Of The Oxydracae |
||
5 |
Book 12: June 325BC June 324BC |
121 |
Southern India And Its
Ocean, The Kedrosian Desert And The Return to Persia (click here to view
PDF) |
||
6 |
Alexander's Route Through India |
142 |
7 |
Organisation And Sources |
144 |
8 |
Bibliography |
176 |
9 |
Acknowledgements |
181 |
|
Index |
182 |
Images
|
|
|
Figure
10.2. The assault on Aornus across the ravine (Antonio Tempesta, 1608) |
Figure
10.3. The phalanx attacks at the Hydaspes (Andr� Castaigne, 1899) |
Figure
11.3. Alexander�s lone defence within the Indian citadel (anonymous,
1696)
|
Sample Chapter
How to Buy
|
|
Reviews
The
following review of Alexander the Great in India has been posted by Fiona on
Friday 22nd May 2009 on the Alexander the Great Discussion Forum at Pothos and
on the book�s Amazon UK webpage:
http://www.pothos.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3425&start=15#p32554
I have finished reading Alexander the Great in India today, and I enjoyed it so much, I thought I'd write a review. Here it is: This book is by no means only for the expert or the professional historian. Anyone who is interested in Alexander and familiar with the basic story will find much to enjoy. The introductory chapters are full of fascinating information about how the reconstruction was attempted, and I for one learned a great deal about many lost sources and also about the work of scholars of previous generations. There are tables of evidence, and a very useful timeline chart, showing how the lost sources and the extant ones interconnect, but most interesting to me was the way Cleitarchus himself came through, with his background, his own aims, and his style. The reconstruction itself was a totally absorbing read. The clever use of different font styles to indicate the level of certainty is very useful and is not at all off-putting when reading. The sheer coherence of the reconstructed chapters was very striking. It read like the work of one writer, it never seemed like it was patched together. Best of all was the way it shed new light and new perspectives on familiar scenes. Alexander at Mazaga, the battle against Porus, Alexander leaping down alone into the city of the Oxydracae, Ptolemy's near-fatal encounter with a poisoned arrow, the passage of Kedrosia, and the celebrations in Carmania: these were just some among many scenes where the words I was reading brought new and interesting pictures into my mind. It was like reading a freshly-discovered source, and I warmly recommend it.
Press Release
Press Release via
PRWeb 06-April-2009
Book 13: The Death of Alexander the Great
Introduction
The most influential account of the career of Alexander the Great was
penned by Cleitarchus the son of Deinon, a Greek writing in Alexandria
in the decades after Alexander's death. Most of the surviving ancient
texts on Alexander were more or less based upon his work, but every
single copy of the original was discarded or destroyed in antiquity. The
question is: how far might it be possible to reconstruct it from the
secondary writings? In response, this book presents an extensive
reconstruction of Cleitarchus' account of the death of Alexander the
Great in the stifling summer heat of Babylon in 323BC. It sweeps through
a dramatic series of antecedent episodes culminating in the funeral of
Hephaistion. Soon after it climaxes with Alexander's own expiry, then
thunders on into the shock and chaos of the aftermath in a text studded
with eulogistic orations and scintillating speeches. It is a must for
any fascinated by the deep political undercurrents that streamed beneath
a pivotal event in our history.
|
|
Contents
1. |
Introduction |
1 |
|
Is Curtius mainly translating Cleitarchus? Poetical Devices in
Cleitarchus; Fragments that Fit the Thirteenth Book; Babylon as the
Metropolis; Re-Ordering Curtius on the Mutiny at Opis; The Palace
Regiment of the Hypaspists and the Somatophylakes; The Large Lacuna in
Curtius; Hephaistion's Pyre; Hephaistion the Demigod; The Cause of the
Death of Alexander; How Did the Leading Men Split after Alexander's
Death; Arrhidaeus the Fool; The First Division of the Satrapies; Last
Plans; Antipater & Cassander as Regicides; The Itinerant Corpse |
5 |
|
The Flight of
Harpalus; The Exiles Decree; The Mutiny at Opis; Death of Hephaistion;
The Cossaeans; Death in Babylon; Aftermath & Entombment |
50 |
4. |
Organisation And
Sources |
84 |
5. |
Bibliography |
88 |
6. |
Acknowledgements |
94 |
7. |
Index |
95 |
Images
|
|
Figure
13.1. Alexander seizes the leading mutineers at Opis (Andr� Castaigne,
1899) |
Figure
13.3. The death of Alexander (1696) |
How to Buy
|
|
Reviews
Amazon UK Reviews:
Fascinating evocation of a long lost history of Alexander, 26 May 2010, by Mr. A. G. Batt
Andrew Michael Chugg has
in recent years written a series of excellent and informative books on
Alexander, and this latest publication is no exception.
Following on
chronologically from his earlier book Alexander in India: A Reconstruction of
Cleitarchus, The Death of Alexander the great offers a reconstruction of
Cleitarchus 13th and final book covering Alexanders return from India until his
death in Babylon.
We know that Cleitarchus
wrote probably the most influential ancient account of Alexanders life, and
although it has not survived, it was used to varying degrees by most of the
surviving ancient accounts of Alexander including those by Curtius, Diodorus,
Justin and Plutarch. By going through these surviving sources Chugg has cleverly
managed to ascertain (delineated with various degrees of probability) how these
sources quoted from Cleitarchus original account. With this done, the passages
have then been melded chronologically to imitate the original book.
The chapters prior to the
reconstruction examine in detail events leading up to Alexander's death, and
interpret his final illness - its causes and symptoms so effectively that the
reader feels that any mystery surrounding his death has now been definitively
explained.
The reconstruction itself
is so brilliantly done, that the reader feels they are having the unique
privilege of reading a primary ancient source on Alexander. It flows seamlessly
and fizzes with all the action, drama and atmosphere that one could wish for and
that Cleitarchus intended. Certainly one emerges with a richer interpretation of
Alexander after reading this, so coherent does it seem. And this is not just a
literary device cleverly employed, for in assembling this book Chugg gives us a
deeper understanding of Cleitarchus' book, its influence and how ancient primary
sources were used by other authors in the generations following their creation.
This enjoyable and
fascinating book will satisfy scholars and casual readers alike with its mix of
analysis of the ancient texts, and its exciting and highly readable
reconstruction. Chugg has plans to deliver as complete a reconstruction of the
other Cleitarchus books as possible, and I for one really look forward to the
next instalment.
A titanic job, nothing
less. What Andrew Chugg has done in this book is comparing the surviving texts
from Curtius, Diodorus and Justin to filter out the original work these authors
have used themselves to filter out what was written by Cleitarchus of
Alexandria. To a lesser extent Chugg also includes Arrian, although this author
mainly based his book on the texts left by Ptolemy, and the Metz Epitome. A very
handy drawing with the links used by each and every author in antiquity is quite
revealing.
Cleitarchus, son of
Deinon wrote his account in the decades following Alexander's death and most of
the surviving ancient texts were more or less based upon his work, although not
a single copy has come to us since they all were destroyed or discarded at some
time or another.
Chugg manages to pinpoint
which texts or phrases are used commonly by Curtius and Diodorus, with
eventually an addition when Justin uses the same words. A Table overview
accounting for the matches is very helpful. And so is the Table showing the
first division of the Satrapies soon after Alexander's death in Babylon listing
each territory with the name of the appointed governor (satrap) as given by
Diodorus, Justin, Curtius, Cleitarchus himself, as well as separately by Arrian,
Dexippus and the Metz Epitome. Sounds all very technical but it becomes quite
interesting when in the end we are able to read this part of Alexander's history
as it was presumably put down by Cleitarchus in the first place. A daring
undertaking but a highly interesting one.
Most of Chugg's book is centered around Cleitarchus' Book 13, covering the
period from July 324 BC to July 323 BC and beyond, i.e. the very last year of
Alexander's life. The subjects treated here are many: the Flight of Harpalus;
the Exiles Decrees, the Mutiny at Opis; Death of Hephaistion; The Cosseans;
Death in Babylon; Aftermath and Entombment. After a detailed comment and
investigation of each chapter, one can read the full text as it may have been
put down by Cleitarchus initially. A captivating story, especially since certain
paragraphs have been put back in their original sequence ensuring the continuity
of events.
The book ends again with
a Table giving for each episode in Cleitarchus terms the corresponding sources
and references with additional comments in the last column. If after all that
you still have questions, please do get in touch with Andrew Chugg in person.
5-stars: Classic reborn, April 11, 2010 By Gino Litvak
Absolute must have for anyone interested in the subject of Alexander or Ancient
Greek/Macedonian history A real gem!